Word on the college basketball street is that Derrick Rose — currently of the Chicago Bulls, formerly of the University of Memphis Tigers — was not eligable for his freshman season because of an “invalidated standardized test score” in high school. Memphis made it to the NCAA Finals that season, riding Rose’s coattails, and he subsequently became the #1 pick in the NBA draft. Some may look at this as just another college sports scandal involving a high profile player and a high profile coach (John Calipari, who has left the program for the greener, bluegrass pastures of Kentucky). But this highlights a fundamental flaw in the much criticized NCAA and NBA.
When NBA Commissioner David Stern instigated the rule that you had to be a certain age to enter the NBA Draft, he was following in the footsteps of the NFL, which has a similar rule. But this was a flawed decision. The NFL rule stemmed from the fact that football is a much more physical game than basketball and for kids coming out before they were ready there were serious consequences for not being physically up-to-snuff. Stern made the decision following some high-profile, straight out of high school players washing out of the league and washing up on the Jersey Shore. OK, that last bit was a little exaggerated, but you get the idea. He was attempting to protect these immature high school athletes from getting too much, too soon and not being able to handle it. It was a decision based on the mentality, not physicality, of a high schooler.
The world of basketball in America has always been notoriously corrupt and shady, from the top down. From fixed drafts and playoff games, to booster sponsored college programs, to ABCD and Nike summer camps, to street agents latching onto preteens in the ghetto. It permeates all levels of the game, NBA to YMCA, and this is just another example of the nature of cheating that surrounds basketball. The rule that Stern implemented had more of an impact on the college game than the pro. In fact, it changed the landscape of college basketball forever. Used to be, a high school phenom skipped college and entered the draft — see King James, Kevin Garnett, The Black Mamba, etc. But now, because they have to be one year removed from high school to enter, they need a place to play/kill time before they cash in. This is where college basketball comes in, and coaches like John Calipari have taken full advantage.
Players like Rose, Kevin Durant, and Micheal Beasley have no incentive to attend college other than this rule. They put in their year, dominate like men among boys, then bolt for the draft. This puts the pressure on college coaches to determine if it is worth recruiting a player that will only be there for one year, and has explicitly said so. Some, like Calipari, embrace/exploit these one-hit-wonders with much success, while others do not.
This rule has had other major repercussions also. A player like Rose, and this recent revelation of his invalidated SAT/ACT is at the heart of the matter. Stern has encouraged this type of overt cheating with the draft age limit. The only motivation that a kid has for even taking the SAT/ACT now is so he can play hoops for a year before he’s eligible. This means he has added pressure to perform well and get into school and will do what it takes to get there, using the resources — I’m not talking Kaplan here — available, which are numerous. This results in the situation we have with Rose and Memphis. The big losers are the Universities who get duped into taking these kids then get burned when they get caught cheating. The other losers are the hoops players who actually want to go to college, but have their scholarships gobbled up by players just skating through so they can have an NBA career. That is the real travesty.
The flip side of the coin is: why should these amazing athletes be forced to spend a year dunking on college kids when they should be passing to a superstar? The situation is becoming more absurd with the realization that these high school stars can spend a year playing pro ball in Europe and then return to the NBA, skipping college game altogether. They do not even need to graduate high school, but can skip their senior, or even junior year to play overseas for a couple seasons AND get payed.